regarding Heroes 2x07, and Mohinder (part 1)
I like Mohinder.
I'm one of the few people in the world who liked him from very early on.
I liked his conflicting emotions about his father's research, how he wanted to protect it and prove it, but how he was also impatient and angry with himself for still wanting Chandra's approval after all these years. I loved his banter with Eden; to this day, I still think she was his only true "match", a person who would obviously care about and care for him, never dismissing his emotions or issues, but who also knows his stubborn nature, accepts it all, and counters it with reason and humour.
Mohinder cares about people, on a fundamental level, and wants to guide them and save them, and is clearly of the opinion that science is of no use in and of itself, that research is only relevant when it can be applied, and applied for good. This is why he leaves India for the second time. This is why he refuses to experiment with the virus. But he seems to dislike most people he meets, and they seems to be annoyed by him, and it all makes me giggle. It's understandable, of course. At the same time as being kind and helpful on a, what should we say, theoretical level, Mohinder is also impatient, impulsive, rude, stubborn (I've said this one twice now), and at times even smug and superior. I love all of that about him. He wants to help people and he's idealistic, but he has little social skill, has to try very hard whenever he needs to be diplomatic, and isn't actually very nice or open or, God forbid, meek.
Mohinder knows the difference between the general and the specific, between the conceptual and the concrete. He is a scientist, he knows that some species have eradicated and will continue to eradicate other species, he knows this is how evolution works. On some level, I believe he knows there's no way for him to tell whether Sylar is an agent of this evolutionary process, or plain psychotic. But he knows that in this concrete situation, he will kill Sylar. He knows that in that cencrete situation, he will stop Sylar from committing genocide -- even though he himself wrote of the very clear possibility of genocide. Mohinder sees the line between theory and practise, and is highly concerned with what he believes is morally right, over what he might understand to be scientific fact. Mohinder has no doubt about which he will choose, not even as Sylar sees his dichotomy of science and morals and mercilessly provokes it.
The above is how I understand Mohinder as a scientist and man. I also believe this is how Chandra understood Mohinder, hence the "heart of stone" comment. Mohinder can't commit to science alone, it's not in him. Perhaps said in other words, Mohinder would not have made Sylar. Even if he had, Mohinder would have committed himself to stop what he made, not simply distance himself as Chandra did. This is why, in the Sylar storyline, Chandra dies and Mohinder comes to the US.
That leads me to 2x07. But alas, I have no more time; must shower and leave. Wah!





